“Fusion” and “Exclusion” of Daoism to Zipingshu——Perspective on Ziwei doushu and Rumen chongli zhezhong kanyu wanxiao lu in Daoist Cannon

Abstract

Abstract: Daoism has a close relationship with Shushu(術數）, and there are many Shushu literatures in Daoism, but this does not mean that Daoism is open to Shushu. The Zipingshu is not seen in the Daoist Cannon of Ming dynasty, but in Ziwei doushu(紫微斗數）and Rumen chongli zhezhong kanyu wanxiaolu（儒門崇理折衷堪輿完孝錄）. Besides, none of the people from either Daoism or not edited Zipingshu in Daoist collections, which reflects Daoist attitude of "fusion" and "exclusion" to Zipingshu. This article points out that this contradictory attitude is determined by the religious nature of Daoism and Zipingshu’s “atheism” characteristics, and also discuss the rationality of Zengzhu xinxiu daozang mulu（增注新修道藏目錄）contains the Xindiao zhushu luolunzi sanming xiaoxifu（新雕注疏珞琭子三命消息賦）

Key words: Daoism, Shushu(術數）, Ziping, Bazi（八字）

Luo Xi. “Fusion” and “Exclusion” of Daoism to Zipingshu——Perspective on Ziwei doushu and Rumen chongli zhezhong kanyu wanxiao lu in Daoist Cannon[J]. Daoism Studies, 2021(1): 110-125.

References

(1)傳統文獻
《抱朴子》[Baopuzi]，《道藏》[The Daoist Canon] (北京[Beijing]:文物出版社[Cultural Relics Press]，上海[Shanghai]:上海書店[Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House ]，天津[Tianjin]: 天津古籍出版社[Tianjin Ancient Works Publishing House]，1988)，第28冊[vol. 28]。
程敏政Chen Minzheng:《皇明文衡》[Huangming wenheng] (上海[Shanghai]:上海商務印書館[Shanghai Commercial Press]，1919)。
《道藏闕經目錄》[Daozang quejing mulu]，《道藏》[The Daoist Canon] (北京 [Beijing]:文物出版社[Cultural Relics Press]，上海[Shanghai]:上海書店[Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House]，天津[Tianjin]:天津古籍出版社[Tianjin Ancient Works Publishing House], 1988)，第34冊[vol.34]。
《洞真黄書》[Dongzhen huangshu]，《道藏》[The Daoist Canon] (北京[Beijing]: 文物出版社[Culural Relics Press]，上海[Shanghai]:上海書店[Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House ],天津[Tianjin]:天津古籍出版社[Tianjin Ancient Works Publishing House], 1988)，第 33册[vol.33]。
《穀神篇》[Gushen pian]，《道藏》[The Daoist Canon] (北京[Beijing]:文物出版社 [Cultural Relics Press]，上海[Shangha]:上海書店[Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House]，天津[Tianjin]: 天津古籍出版社[Tianjin Ancicnt Works PublishingHousel, 1988),第4册[vol.4]。
《黄帝太乙八門入式訣》(Huangdli taiyo bamen rushi jue]，《道藏》[The Daoist Canon] (北京[Beijing]:文物出版社[Cultural Relics Press]，上海[Shanghai]:上海書店[Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House]，天津[Tianjin]:天津古籍出版社[Tianjin Ancient Works Publishing House], 1988),第10冊[vol.10]。
《九天應元雷聲普化天尊玉樞寶經》[Jiutian yingruan leisheng puhua tianzun yushu baojing，《道藏》[The Daoist Canon] (北京[Beijing]:文物出版社[Culural Relics Press], 上海[Shanghai]:上海書店[Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House],天津[Tianjin]: 天津古籍出版社[Tianjin Ancient Works Publishing House]，1988)，第1冊[vol. 1]。
蘭陵笑笑生Lanling Xiaoxiao Sheng著:《金瓶梅詞話 (梅節重校本)》Jinpingmei cibua (Meijie Rerised)] (香港[Hongkong]:夢梅館(Mengmei House], 1992)。
《珞球子三命消息賦注》[Luoluozi sanming xiaoxi fuzhu]，《景印文渊閣四庫全書.子部一一五·術數類》Jingyin wenyuangesiku quanshu·zibu 115·shushulei] (臺北[Taipei]: 臺灣商務印書館[Taiwan commercial Press,)。
《靈劍子引導子午記》[Lingjian zi yindao ziwu ji，《道藏》[The Daist Canon] (北京 [Beijing]:文物出版社[Cultural Relics Press]，上海(Shanghai]:上海書店[Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House ]，天津[Tianjin]:天津古籍出版社[Tianjin Ancient Works Publishing House], 1988),第10冊[vol.10]。
《璽寶六丁秘法》[Zingbao liuding bif]，《道藏》[The Daoist Canon] (北京[Beijing]: 文物出版社[Cultural Relics Press]，上海[Shanghai]:上海書店[Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House ],天津[Tianjin]: 天津古籍出版社[Tianjin Ancient Wortks Publishing House], 1988)，第10冊[vol.10]。
《六十甲子本命元辰曆》[Liushi jazi benming yuanchen li，《道藏》[The Daoist Canon] (北京[Beijing]:文物出版社[Cultural Relics Press]，上海[Shanghai]:上海書店 [Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House]，天津[Tianjin]:天津古籍出版社[Tianjin Ancient Works Publishing House, 1988),第32冊[vol. 32]。
《儒門崇理折衷堪奧完孝錄》[Rumen chongli zhezhong kanyu wanxiao lu]，《道藏》[The Daoist Canon] (北京[Beijing]:文物出版社[Cultural Relics Press]，上海[Shanghai]: 上海書店[Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House]，天津[Tianjin]:天津古籍出版社[Tianjin Ancient Works Publishing House]，1988),第35冊[vol.35]。
沈孝瞻Shen Xiaozhan撰:《子平真詮》[Ziping zhenquan]，鄭同點校[Zhengtong Proofread]，《四庫存目·子平葉刊·秘本子平真詮》[Siku cunmu·Ziping huikan·Miben zipping zhenquan] (北京[Beijing]:華齡出版社[Hualing Press], 2014)。
《太上洞玄靈寶异玄內教經卷第八(顯真戒品)》[Taishang dongxuan lingbao shengxuan nejjao jingjuan cdiba (Xianzhen, Jiepin)]，李德范Li Defan輯，《敦煌道藏 (四)》[DunhuangDaoistCannon](北京[Beijing]:中華全國圖書館文獻縮微複裂中心[National Library of China Documents Microform Copy Cneter], 1999), 第4冊[vol.4]。
萬明英Wan Mingying著:《三命通會》[Sanming tonghui]，《景印文淵閣四庫全書·子部一一六·術數類》Jingvin wenyuange siku quanshu·zibu 116·Shushu lei] (臺北[Taipei]: 臺灣商務印書館[Traiwan commercial Press])。
《新雕詿疏珞琭子三命消息賦》[Xindiao zhushu luolu zi sanming xiaoxi fu]，《續修四庫全書·1059·子部·術數類》[Xuxiu siku quanshu·1059·zibu·shushu lei] (上海 [Shanghai]:上海古籍出版社[Shanghai Ancient Works Publishing house], 2002)。
《元辰章醮立成曆》[Yuanchen zhangjiao licheng li，《道藏》[The Daoist Canon] (北京[Beijing]:文物出版社[Cultural Relics Press]，上海[Shanghai]:上海書店[Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House]，天津[Tianjin]:天津古籍出版社[Tianjin Ancient Works Publishing House]，1988),第 32冊[vol.32]。
《新刊合饼官板音義評詿淵海子平》[Xinkan hebing guanban yinyi pingzhu yuanhai ziping]，故官博物院The Palace Museum編，《故宫珍本叢刊》[Gugong zhenben congkan] (海口[Haikou]:海南出版社[Hainan Publishing house]，2000)，第422冊[vol.422]。
《紫微斗數》[Ziwei doushu]，《道藏》[The Daoist Canon] (北京[Beijing]:文物出版社[Culural Relics Press]，上海[Shanghai]:上海書店[Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House],天津[Tianjing):天津古籍出版社[Tianjin Ancient Works Publishing House], 1988),第36冊[vol. 36]。
趙翼Zhaoyi著、欒保群Luan Baoqun，呂宗力Lv Zongli校點:《陔餘叢考》 [Gaiyu congkao] (石家莊[Shijiazhuang]:河北人民出版社[Hebei People’s Publishing House], 1990)
《正一法文天師教戒科經》[Zhengvi fawen tianshi jaojieke jing]，《道藏》[The Daoist Canon] (北京[Beijing]:文物出版社[Cultural Relics Press]，上海[Shanghai]:上海書店 [Shanghai Bookstore Publishing House]，天津[Tianjin]:天津古籍出版社[Tianjin Ancient Works Publishing House]，1988),第18冊[vol.18]。
戴冠Daiguan:《濯纓亭筆記》[Zhuoyingting biji] (高等學校中英文圖書數位化國際合作計書[Gaodeng xuexiao zhongyingwen tushu shuweihua guoi hezuo jihua])。
(2)近人論著
陳攖寧Chen Yingning著:《道教與養生》[Daoism and Health]，(北京[Being]:華文出版社[Chinese words Press]，1989)。
丁培仁著Ding Peiren:《增注新修道藏目錄》[Zengzhu xinxiu daozang mulu] (成都[Chengdu]:巴蜀書社[Bashu Publishing House]，2008)。
蓋建民Gai Jianming著:《道教術數與傳統數學思想考析》[“Analysis of Daoist Shushu and Traditional Mathematical Thoughts”]，《宗教學研究》Religious Study, no. 4 (2006): 6-12。
胡孚琛Hu fuchen著:《道學通論》[General Theory of Daoism] (北京[Beijing]:社會科學文獻出版社[Social Sciences Academic Press (China)]，2009)。
胡孚琛Hu Fuchen:《中華道教大辭典》[Chinese Daoist Dictionary] (北京[Beijing]: 中國社會科學出版社[China Social Science Publishing House]，1996)。
牟玄Mouxuan:《正續<道藏>所見術數文獻芻議》["Discussion on the Shushu Books in Daozang and Xudaozang" ]，《北方論叢》The Northern Forum, no. 5 (2016): 26-30。
卿希泰Qing Xitai主編、詹石窗Zhan Shichuang副主編:《中國道教思想史》[History of Chinese Daoist Thoughts]，第一卷[vol.1] (北京[Beijing]:人民出版社(People’s Publishing House]，2009)。
任繼愈Ren Jiyu、鍾肇鹏Zhong Zhaopeng主編:《道藏提要》[Synopsis of Daoist Collection] (北京[Beijing]:中國社會科學出版社[China Social Science Publishing House], 1991)，1163。
孫偉傑Sun Weijie、蓋建民Gai Jianmin:《黄道十二宫與道教關傑考論》[“A Research on Zodiac and Taoism”]，《中國哲學史》The History of Chinese Philosophy, no. 4 (2015): 74-82.
蕭登福Xiao Dengfu著:《正統道藏提要》[Synopsis of Zhengtong Daoist Collection] (壹北[Taibei]:文津出版社[Wenjin Publishing House], 2011)
謝路軍Xie Lujun:《漫話術數》[“About Shushu”]，《中國民族報(宗教遇刊·人文)》China Ethnic News . Religious. Humanity, (2019.1.8)， 7 Edition.
中村璋八Zhongcun Zhangba、安居香山Anju Xiangshan輯:《緯書集成》[The Collection of Augury Texts] (石家莊[Shijiazhuang]:河北人民出版社[Hebei People’s Publishing House]，1994),下冊[vol.2]。

[1]	Guo Jiaxing, Hu Rui. The Daoist-Relevant Literatures in Morrison Collection of Chinese Books [J]. Daoism Studies, 2021, 37(1): 1-12.
[2]	Yuan Yumei. A Brief Analysis of the Fourth Patriarch of the Southern Lineage Daoism Chen Nan's Biography [J]. Daoism Studies, 2021, 37(1): 78-86.
[3]	Zhang Lei. Recognition of the Relationship Between Daoism and Folk Beliefs and Its Social Functions [J]. Daoism Studies, 2021, 37(1): 126-137.
[4]	Yu Guoqing, Li Xiao. On the Thought of "Quantifying the Merits and Demerits"of the Daoist Morality Books [J]. Daoism Studies, 2020, 36(2): 25-33.
[5]	Wan Xiaoyan. Research on the Thoughts of Preventive Medicine in Daoism [J]. Daoism Studies, 2020, 36(2): 74-89.
[6]	Ye Wenxue. Exposition on Daoist Fire Official Cult in Dali [J]. Daoism Studies, 2020, 36(2): 135-155.
[7]	Fan Bingce. A New Exploration of Liang Shuming's Daoist Thought [J]. Daoism Studies, 2020, 36(2): 156-169.
[8]	Sun Weijie. The Astronomy Essentials in the Daoist Alchemy of Sui, Tang and Five Dynasties [J]. Daoism Studies, 2020, 35(1): 149-159.
[9]	Geng Qiongke. Psychological Interpretation of Nüdan in Daoism [J]. Daoism Studies, 2020, 35(1): 172-185.
[10]	Gao Deng. Control Hun and Change Po：An Analysis of Hun and Po in Daoist Texts [J]. Daoism Studies, 2019, 34(2): 64-75.
[11]	Zhu Zhanyan. The Daoist Altar, Literature, and Sects in the Mountainous County of Eastern Guangxi—Taking Zhaoping County of Hezhou City as the Center [J]. Daoism Studies, 2019, 34(2): 76-91.
[12]	Liu Yuxia. On Shen Yue's Poems of Immortality and His Daoist Belief [J]. Daoism Studies, 2019, 34(2): 92-121.
[13]	Liu Jincheng. Research on the Yi in Daoist Elixir Scriptures from Tang Dynasty [J]. Daoism Studies, 2019, 34(2): 132-147.